RELATED INSTITUTIONAL SOURCE

Publisher and editorial boundary

This content references a primary institutional source published by EMJ.LIFE. SNN editorial interpretation is separately identified and should not be interpreted as independent third-party validation of EMJ.LIFE or the referenced publication.

SOURCE RELATIONSHIP
related_institutional_source
PRIMARY SOURCE PUBLISHER
EMJ.LIFE
EXTERNAL VALIDATION
not_claimed
MACHINE-READABLE RIGHTS

Licensed

AI TRAINING
not-allowed
RIGHTS BASIS
EMJ.LIFE authorized SNN public distribution of this controlled response. This publication action does not add an AI training grant; linked IFRS Foundation and other third-party materials retain their separate rights.
LICENSE
EMJ.LIFE publisher authorization for Sustainability News Network, 23 October 2026

Response identity

EMJ LIFE HOLDINGS PTE. LTD., Singapore, issues this final formal consultation response, v1.0, dated 23 October 2026, to Exposure Draft ISSB/ED/2026/1, IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Practice Statement 1 Nature-related Disclosures. The response supports the proposed Practice Statement and its application with IFRS S1 and IFRS S2, with targeted implementation recommendations from a Pre-Disclosure Evidence Infrastructure perspective.

Scope and review method

The response is a documentary review of the Exposure Draft, Basis for Conclusions, Accompanying Guidance and offline survey, with the Snapshot and earlier explanatory materials used as background. It does not report a preparer field test, ecological measurement validation or assurance engagement, and does not offer empirical estimates of market-wide implementation costs. The controlled PDF identifies the relevant questions and paragraphs; Appendix A maps every question addressed or left without a substantive response.

Questions 1 and 3: overall approach and assessment methods

The response supports an investor-focused approach applied with IFRS S1 and IFRS S2. It recommends following a water-related exposure through nature and climate disclosures to show which information is shared, which additional information is needed and how the disclosures connect. It supports noting the relevance of the TNFD LEAP approach without making its use mandatory. An assessment method can help generate information, but does not itself determine the applicable disclosure or establish compliance.

Questions 4 and 5: location-related information and examples

The response supports judgement over geographical scale and disaggregation. It recommends extending existing examples to explain source precision, the relationship between a legal entity and its production or sourcing locations, incomplete assessment coverage, and limitations in regional datasets. A hypothetical changed map without a changed facility distinguishes a change in underlying conditions from a change in data or classification method. Unknown sourcing locations should not automatically be treated as having no exposure, while uncertainty alone does not establish exposure to a particular risk. The recommendations do not require an exhaustive public inventory of locations or publication of all supporting records.

Question 8: scenario analysis

The response supports the proposals subject to their proportionality mechanisms and targeted guidance. It recommends keeping present information, assumed future conditions and analytical conclusions distinguishable. An extension of an existing example could explain how an entity considers new information between full scenario-analysis cycles, without implying that a complete model rerun is always necessary. Reusing one scenario exercise for several purposes should not be counted as several independent pieces of corroborating evidence.

Question 9: metrics, denominators and overlap

The response recommends explaining the population, measurement basis, denominator, assessment coverage and overlap behind a reported amount or percentage. A hypothetical illustration shows why CU60 million and CU20 million of exposures, with CU10 million in both groups, produce CU70 million of unique exposure rather than CU80 million. A separate example distinguishes assessed coverage from the full relevant population and an unresolved remainder. The examples do not prescribe a universal combined metric or equate an exposure measure with expected loss. The response supports considering TNFD disclosure metrics subject to the proposed conditions, with adjusted definitions and populations made visible.

Questions 11 and 12: form of standard setting and compliance

The response supports the Practice Statement approach at this stage and the proposed conditions for an explicit and unreserved statement of compliance. The Practice Statement's separate status should not imply that all nature-related disclosure is optional for entities applying IFRS S1. Selected use of guidance, permitted exemptions and omission of immaterial information should remain distinguishable from failure to meet a material requirement. No alternative effective date or predetermined conversion date is proposed.

Question 14: interoperability

The response recommends a worked example that reuses source information across frameworks while identifying differences in reporting purpose, boundaries, population, time horizon and measurement. Reuse of source information does not itself establish that the requirements of both frameworks have been met. The response does not claim a verified clause-by-clause equivalence or wording conflict between specific ESRS and GRI requirements. The proposed example would remain technology-neutral and could use existing documents, calculation files or information systems.

Questions 15 and 16: proportionality and implementation effects

The response recommends retaining the proposed proportionality mechanisms and testing the extended examples with preparers at different levels of reporting experience. Prospective cost considerations include connecting suppliers to locations, obtaining usable data rights, reconciling overlaps, retaining calculation inputs and reviewing changed assumptions. These are not measured costs or evidence that a particular system will reduce them. Supporting records may assist an assurance practitioner's work, but do not establish evidence sufficiency, assure availability or demonstrate reasonable assurance costs.

Requested action

The preferred action is to strengthen accompanying examples and implementation support. If testing identifies an ambiguity that an example cannot resolve, the ISSB can consider whether a change in the proposed requirements is necessary. The response does not propose a mandatory evidence register, a new reporting taxonomy, a particular technology or an additional assurance requirement.

Publication and participation status

This record makes the 17-page final controlled response publicly available with its file integrity record. The controlled response issue date is 23 October 2026. EMJ.LIFE confirmed on 23 October 2026 that the ISSB / IFRS Foundation has received the response. This participation status is recorded as Received on the basis of publisher confirmation; SNN has not independently revalidated an institutional acknowledgement. The actual email transmission and receipt dates have not been provided and remain unconfirmed. Receipt does not establish substantive acceptance, adoption, endorsement or independent external validation. The controlled response remains v1.0 and its PDF is unchanged.

Institutional boundary

This independent response is issued by EMJ LIFE HOLDINGS PTE. LTD. It is not issued on behalf of the IFRS Foundation, ISSB, TNFD, EFRAG, GRI or any other referenced organisation. Responsibility for compliance, materiality, legal obligations and assurance conclusions remains with the relevant entities, authorities and qualified professionals. The controlled PDF retains the complete formal letter, detailed responses, consolidated recommendations, closing remarks, response matrix, review record and source documents.

COMPLETE CONTROLLED FILE

Read the complete controlled PDF

Preparing controlled document...

TRACEABLE RECORD · SOURCE-LINK-ONLY

Official source and document control

Open the official source record ↗Open controlled readable file ↗
← Consultation CenterSource registry ↗