Publisher and editorial boundary
This content references a primary institutional source published by EMJ.LIFE. SNN editorial interpretation is separately identified and should not be interpreted as independent third-party validation of EMJ.LIFE or the referenced publication.
- SOURCE RELATIONSHIP
- related_institutional_source
- PRIMARY SOURCE PUBLISHER
- EMJ.LIFE
- EXTERNAL VALIDATION
- not_claimed
Licensed
- AI TRAINING
- not-allowed
- RIGHTS BASIS
- EMJ.LIFE authorized SNN public distribution of this controlled response. This publication action does not add an AI training grant; linked EFRAG materials retain their separate rights.
- LICENSE
- EMJ.LIFE publisher authorization for Sustainability News Network, 20 October 2026
Response identity
EMJ LIFE HOLDINGS PTE. LTD., Singapore, completed the EFRAG Revised ESRS Draft XBRL Taxonomy September 2026 online questionnaire on 20 October 2026. This record publishes the 13-page v1.1 Controlled Public Response prepared for public archiving after that survey session. It records support with targeted technical recommendations from a Pre-Disclosure Evidence Infrastructure perspective.
Scope and review method
The technical review inspected the September draft package, the Technical Explanatory Note and ESRS 2 paragraph 37(g) in EFRAG's Knowledge Hub. Two package downloads on 19 October 2026 produced matching digests. This was static XML and documentation inspection, not full discoverable taxonomy set validation, processor interoperability testing or a preparer field test. The technical source review cut-off remains 19 October 2026. Expanded-form numbering and submission evidence were reviewed on 20 October 2026.
Questions 7 and 8: overall assessment and suggestions
The response agrees in general with the draft taxonomy, with targeted improvements. It requests clarification of the materiality member label, conditionality metadata and the distinction between reported values and absence. Missing information should not be interpreted automatically as zero, non-material, not applicable or non-compliant. Taxonomy labels and examples should preserve the meaning supported by the underlying requirements without creating additional substantive ESRS disclosure obligations.
The static inspection of esrs-reference.xml found 225 ConditionalityOrAlternativePresentation occurrences, resolving to 163 distinct concept fragments and 130 distinct DatapointId values. Exact lexical values comprised 159 occurrences of Conditional, 44 of Alternative presentation and 22 of Conditional followed by a space. These are different counting units. They do not establish ESRS completeness or an XBRL validation failure. The response requests reconciliation of documentation and metadata, explicit normalisation rules and worked examples for alternatives.
Questions 9 and 10: Level-1 narrative elements
The response supports retaining Level-1 narrative elements alongside entity-specific elements, with comments. Whole-Disclosure-Requirement textblocks can preserve context and navigation, while granular and entity-specific elements identify more specific disclosures. The response requests examples covering overlap, source order and extraction so that the same passage is not counted repeatedly as independent evidence. Retaining elements in the taxonomy does not prejudge the mandatory tagging rules to be established by the relevant authorities.
Question 11: timing of additional validation rules
The response agrees with introducing additional XBRL validation rules after the first wave of digital ESRS disclosures has been published. First-wave experience can inform rule priorities and feasibility. Rules should identify their scope, applicability, severity and limits, with a clear distinction between technical checks and completeness or compliance assessments. Passing a validation rule does not establish substantive ESRS compliance or assurance.
Question 12: other comments
The response recommends maintaining package revision identifiers, change logs and file or package digests independently of a stable taxonomy namespace. The reviewed project page recorded package publication on 17 September and replacement of esrs-reference.xml on 18 September, while the schema entry point used 2026-08-30. These dates serve different purposes. A namespace date alone does not identify the corrected package used for analysis.
Questionnaire and publication control
The expanded questionnaire contains Q7 as the overall assessment, Q8 as its suggestions field, Q9 as the Level-1 narrative question, Q10 as its comments field, Q11 as the validation-timing question and Q12 as other comments. Appendix D of the controlled PDF maps these items and reproduces the three field texts supplied for the completed session. It is not a platform-generated export certifying the exact transmitted answers.
Submission evidence and authority boundary
The respondent supplied the survey completion screen bearing the EFRAG survey title and Thank You message. It supports recording completion of the online submission on 20 October 2026. No unique response identifier, exact completion time or platform-generated response export was supplied. The public PDF was prepared after completion and is not represented as a file transmitted through the survey. Submission, public archiving, institutional acceptance and adoption are separate events. No EFRAG endorsement, external validation or regulatory recognition is inferred.
Version record
Version 1.0 was prepared on 19 October 2026 for submission. Version 1.1, dated 20 October 2026, corrects the expanded questionnaire numbering, separates the three text fields, records the completion evidence and removes filling instructions. The underlying technical recommendations are retained. The controlled PDF includes the response overview, detailed technical responses, consolidated recommendations, closing remarks, response matrix, publication and submission boundary, technical review record, online questionnaire record and source documents.
Read the complete controlled PDF
Preparing controlled document...
